How to Write a Follow Up Email With No Response That Works

Sending an email into a silent inbox is a common frustration. But a lack of response is rarely bad luck. It's usually the result of avoidable mistakes like a generic message, poor timing, or a vague call to action.

This guide provides actionable best practices to help you write a follow up email with no response that gets results.

Why Your Follow-Up Emails Get Ignored

A busy inbox is a common excuse, but the real reasons often lie in your email's strategy and content. Pinpointing these issues is the first step toward writing follow-ups that get replies.

The most common mistake is a self-serving approach. Messages focused entirely on what you need, without offering value in return, are quickly deleted. An inbox is a competitive space, and emails that don't provide immediate, clear value are ignored.

The Psychology of a Cluttered Inbox

Every unread email represents another task. When your follow-up feels like a chore, it gets ignored.

A vague "just checking in" email is the worst offender. It forces the recipient to recall your last conversation and figure out what you want. This mental friction is often enough to prevent a reply. Effective follow-ups are clear, concise, and helpful. They do the heavy lifting for the recipient and immediately answer the question: "What's in this for me?"

Best Practice: Shift from 'checking in' to providing genuine value. Your goal isn't just to remind them you exist; it's to make them glad you did.

The High Cost of Giving Up Too Soon

Persistence is a significant competitive advantage. Data shows that 70% of cold emails never receive a single follow-up, yet 55% of replies come from those follow-up messages.

Most sales require multiple touchpoints, but nearly half of all salespeople give up after one attempt. To see the full email engagement findings, you can review the full data.

Success is in the follow-up, which is precisely where most people stop. By committing to a structured follow-up strategy, you position yourself to cut through the noise and earn a response.

Nailing Your Follow-Up Cadence and Timing

Effective timing is as crucial as the content of your email. Sending a follow-up too quickly seems pushy; waiting too long makes you forgettable. The right cadence keeps you top-of-mind without becoming an annoyance.

Before scheduling your follow-ups, understand why emails are ignored in the first place.

As shown, a generic message, poor timing, or a vague call-to-action are the fastest ways to get your email deleted. A consistent, predictable cadence is the best defense against the "bad timing" problem.

A Practical Follow-Up Email Cadence

A planned sequence demonstrates professional persistence while respecting your contact's schedule. Use this 4-step framework as a starting point for a follow-up sequence that builds momentum without being intrusive.

This schedule provides adequate time between messages. Each touchpoint is an opportunity to connect at the right moment, turning a single attempt into a sustained, value-driven conversation.

Context Is Everything: Adapt Your Timing

A rigid, one-size-fits-all schedule is ineffective. Adapt your timing based on the context of the outreach.

Consider these common scenarios:

• Cold Outreach: Use a longer cadence, like the one outlined above, to give prospects space.

• Warm Lead (Post-Demo or Meeting): Shorten the gaps to maintain momentum. A follow-up within 24 hours is standard, with the next one 2-3 days later.

• Proposal Sent: Allow 3–5 business days for internal review and discussion. This timing is proactive yet patient.

Best Practice: Persistence is key. 80% of deals require between 5 and 12 contacts. A sequence of up to 8 emails can double or even triple reply rates. A thoughtful schedule is a fundamental component of a successful outreach strategy.

You can learn more about how to automate this process in our guide to AI-powered lead generation.

Writing Subject Lines That Cut Through the Noise

Your subject line determines whether your email gets opened. With professionals receiving over 120 emails a day, a weak subject line ensures your message is ignored.

The goal is to spark curiosity and demonstrate relevance, compelling them to click. Your subject line is a micro-pitch—you have about seven words to signal that the content inside is valuable. Avoid gimmicks like a fake "Re:" on a new thread; it's a transparent and outdated tactic.

Proven Formulas for Higher Open Rates

Use these battle-tested formulas as adaptable frameworks for your subject lines.

• Reference the Last Interaction: This provides immediate context, jogging the recipient's memory and distinguishing your email from cold outreach. It frames the message as a continuation of a previous conversation.

  • Example: "Following up on our call about [Topic]"

  • Example: "Next steps from our meeting on Tuesday"

• Ask a Sharp, Relevant Question: A direct question engages the brain's problem-solving instinct. Make it specific to a known goal or pain point for maximum impact.

  • Example: "Is [Specific Goal] still a Q3 priority?"

  • Example: "Quick question about your [Project Name]"

Best Practice: A great subject line makes a promise that the email body delivers on. If you create intrigue with a question, ensure the first line of your email immediately addresses it to build trust.

Examples for Different Follow-Up Scenarios

Tailor your subject line to the specific step in your follow-up sequence.

For the First Gentle Nudge (2-3 days later): The objective is simply to bring your email back to the top of their inbox without applying pressure.

• "Circling back on my note from Tuesday"

• "Quick follow up on [Initial Topic]"

For a Value-Add Follow Up (4-5 days later): This email should signal that you are providing something useful, not just asking for a response.

• "Thought you'd find this article on [Their Industry] useful"

• "A resource for your [Company Initiative] goals"

For the Final "Breakup" Email: This message creates polite urgency and can prompt a response from interested but busy contacts by leveraging the fear of missing out.

• "Permission to close your file?"

• "Should I stop reaching out?"

By tailoring your subject line to the context of your follow up email with no response, you significantly increase the probability of getting an open and starting a conversation.

Proven Follow Up Email Templates for Any Situation

Knowing what to say is as important as knowing when to follow up. Generic, copy-paste scripts feel robotic and are ineffective.

The best follow-up emails are flexible frameworks, not rigid templates. Adapt these starting points for specific business scenarios. A follow-up after a demo has a different goal and tone than a final attempt to engage a cold lead. Here are actionable templates designed around psychological triggers to elicit a reply.

The Gentle Nudge After Initial Outreach

Send this first follow-up 2-3 days after your initial email. The goal is to bring your original message to the top of their inbox without being pushy. It is a light, professional reminder that respects their time.

Why it works: It is low-pressure and assumes they were interested but became busy. The helpful, non-demanding tone makes it easy to reply.

Template:

Subject: Circling back on my note

Hi [Name],

I'm bringing my last email to the top of your inbox. I know how hectic things can get.

When you have a moment, I'd love to hear your thoughts on [briefly mention original topic].

Best, [Your Name]

The Follow Up on a Sent Proposal

After sending a proposal, your contact often needs time for review or internal discussion. This follow-up, sent 4-5 days later, is designed to reopen the conversation, clarify questions, and maintain momentum.

Why it works: Instead of asking, "Did you decide yet?" you're asking, "How can I help you decide?" This positions you as a helpful partner rather than a vendor awaiting a signature.

Template:

Subject: Any questions on the proposal?

Hi [Name],

I hope you've had a chance to review the proposal I sent last week.

I wanted to check in to see if you had any questions or if specific areas require further discussion. I'm available to walk through any part of it with your team.

Let me know what a good next step looks like from your end.

Regards, [Your Name]

The Post-Demo Check-In

Silence after a strong demo can be perplexing. This email reminds them of the value discussed and provides a simple next step. Send this within 24-48 hours to capitalize on their initial interest.

Why it works: It reinforces the key benefits and provides a clear, low-friction call-to-action. The less thinking required, the higher the chance of a response. Automating value-driven follow-ups is a key function of modern outbound campaign tools. You can see how this works by checking out the Dexy AI homepage.

Template:

Subject: Next steps after our demo

Hi [Name],

Thank you again for your time yesterday. I enjoyed discussing how [Your Company] can help you achieve [Their Goal].

Based on our conversation, I've attached a one-pager summarizing the key points we covered.

Are you available for a brief call on [Day] to map out the next steps?

Best, [Your Name]

The Strategic "Breakup" Email

After several unanswered follow-ups, the "breakup" email is your final attempt. This message creates polite urgency. By stating you are closing the loop, you often trigger a response from contacts who were interested but procrastinating.

Why it works: This template uses the psychological principle of loss aversion. The prospect of you "closing their file" can motivate a silent contact to reply.

Template:

Subject: Permission to close your file?

Hi [Name],

I have reached out a few times regarding [Topic] but have not heard back, so I will assume this isn't a current priority.

I am closing your file for now. If that’s a mistake, please let me know.

Wishing you and the team all the best.

Regards, [Your Name]

Adding Value to Every Follow-Up Email

The fastest way to be ignored is to send a message that only asks for something. "Just checking in" or "touching base" emails offer no value and place the burden of work on the recipient. They signal that your only goal is a response.

Shift your mindset from being a persistent salesperson to a helpful resource. The primary goal of every follow up email with no response should be to provide something that makes the recipient glad they opened it. This approach transforms your outreach from an interruption into a welcome touchpoint.

Go Beyond Basic Personalization

Using a first name is standard; it is not meaningful personalization. True personalization demonstrates that you have done your research and are invested in their success. It proves you are paying attention to their company, not just your sales quota.

Here are actionable ways to add value:

• Reference a Recent Company Win: Mentioning a new product launch, positive press, or funding round shows you see them as more than a lead. A simple "Congratulations on the new product launch!" is effective.

• Share a Genuinely Useful Article: Find a high-quality article, industry report, or case study directly related to a challenge they face. Frame it as, "I saw this and immediately thought of our conversation about [their specific challenge]."

• Offer a New Insight: Connect a current industry trend to one of their goals. For example, "I recently read a report on [industry trend] and it made me think about your goal to improve [their business objective]. Here’s a quick thought on how that might apply..."

Best Practice: Earn the right to stay in their inbox. Instead of just asking for their time, give them a reason to want to give it to you. Each valuable touchpoint builds trust and rapport, making a reply feel natural.

Practical Examples of Adding Value

Here is a practical application. Imagine you're following up with a prospect who has not responded after a product demo.

Instead of this: Subject: Just checking in "Hi Alex, just wanted to check in and see if you had any thoughts on our demo."

Try this: Subject: A resource for your team "Hi Alex, I saw an article on [relevant topic] today and immediately thought of our conversation about how your team is tackling [specific pain point]. It has some useful data on page 3. Hope your week is going well."

The second email gives before it asks. It provides a no-strings-attached resource that reinforces your position as a helpful expert. For more ideas on crafting compelling messages, explore the communication strategies on the Dexy blog.

Common Follow-Up Mistakes to Avoid

Even the best templates are ineffective if your fundamental approach is flawed. Writing an effective follow-up email is as much about avoiding common mistakes as it is about what you write. It's a fine line between professional persistence and being an annoyance.

Avoid passive-aggressive or guilt-tripping language. Phrases like "Since I haven't heard back..." or "Following up yet again..." put the recipient on the defensive and rarely elicit a positive response.

Vague Requests and Recycled Content

Sending the same message repeatedly is ineffective. If the first email didn't work, sending it again will not produce a different result. Each follow-up must introduce something new—a fresh piece of information, a different angle, or a new resource—to give them a reason to re-engage.

A vague call-to-action (CTA) is equally damaging. Ending an email with "Let me know your thoughts" creates work for the recipient. Instead, make it easy to respond. Ask a simple yes/no question or propose a specific time to connect.

Best Practice: Make replying easier than ignoring. If your follow-up creates more mental work for the recipient, it has already failed.

The biggest mistake is giving up too early. Most responses come from follow-ups, not the initial email. However, there are limits to persistence, and several key mistakes can sabotage your efforts.

Here are specific mistakes to avoid:

• Ignoring Context: The tone and timing for a warm lead should differ significantly from that for a cold prospect. A one-size-fits-all approach does not work.

• Poor Formatting: Large blocks of text are difficult to read, especially on mobile devices. Keep your emails short, scannable, and easy to digest.

• Forgetting Privacy: Sending emails without clear consent or an easy opt-out is a major compliance risk. Respect for recipient data is non-negotiable. You can review our privacy policy to see how we handle user information.

Frequently Asked Questions

Here are answers to the most common questions about follow-up email strategy.

How Many Follow-Ups Is Too Many?

A sequence of 3 to 5 emails is generally the most effective range. Data shows this is where most replies occur.

Sending fewer than three means you are likely leaving opportunities behind. Exceeding five without a response risks becoming an annoyance. As a rule, if you cannot add new value with each message, it is time to pause the sequence.

What's the Best Time to Send a Follow-Up?

Timing is critical. For the first follow-up, wait 2-3 business days to remain top-of-mind without being pushy.

After the first attempt, gradually increase the time between messages: 4-5 days for the next one, then a full week. This maintains persistence without being intrusive. Avoid sending emails on Monday mornings and Friday afternoons. Mid-week, mid-day times, such as Tuesday at 10 AM, consistently show the highest engagement rates.

Best Practice: Always check the recipient's time zone. A well-timed 2 PM email from your location might arrive at 5 AM for them, getting buried before their workday begins.

Should I Reply in the Same Thread or Start a New One?

For the first two follow-ups, reply in the same thread. This keeps the entire conversation in one place, making it easy for the recipient to recall the context.

Consider starting a new thread only on the third or fourth email if you are introducing a completely new angle or a highly compelling piece of content. A fresh subject line can sometimes cut through inbox noise, but use this tactic sparingly. Ensure all outreach aligns with communication standards, as outlined in our terms and conditions of service.

Ready to stop chasing and start closing? DexyAI combines expert human strategy with a powerful AI SDR to run your entire outbound campaign on autopilot. We handle the strategy, personalization, and follow-ups—you just show up for the guaranteed meetings.

Book Your Free Strategy Call